Before You Buy Personal Injury Leads: 10 Checks That Protect Your Budget
By Anthony Bux · VP, Sanguine Legal Solutions
Ten checks to run before buying personal injury leads: five on your own intake, budget and tracking, and five on the provider and its contract.

The short answer
Before you buy personal injury leads, check your own firm first, then the provider. Confirm your case appetite, intake capacity, speed to lead, test budget and tracking to signed cases. Then confirm how the provider generates its traffic, which delivery model fits your team, what “exclusive” means in the contract, the credit policy and the consent records.
Key takeaways
- Most failed lead tests are decided before the first lead arrives, by gaps in intake, budget or tracking.
- Write down your case appetite before you talk to providers. A provider can’t hit a target you haven’t set.
- Your team must call every web form lead within two to three minutes, including evenings and weekends.
- Ask every provider whether it generates its own traffic or buys and resells other people’s.
- “Exclusive,” “qualified” and “credit” mean only what the contract says. Get each one in writing.
- Judge a source by cost per signed case and how many of those cases are still active at 90 days, not by cost per lead.
What does it mean to buy personal injury leads?
Buying personal injury leads means paying a third-party lead provider for inquiries from people who may have an injury claim. The provider runs the advertising and whatever intake steps its delivery model includes, and your firm pays the provider under the terms of your agreement with it.
A third-party lead is an inquiry generated by a company other than your firm, usually from advertising that doesn’t carry your firm’s name. That one fact shapes every check below: the person contacted the provider, not you, and owes your firm nothing. The glossary defines the other terms used here.
Why do most lead tests fail before the first lead arrives?
Most lead tests fail because the firm wasn’t ready, not because the source was bad. Intake that can’t respond fast enough, a budget that ends before cases mature or reporting that stops at lead counts will make a good source look like a bad one.
Anthony Bux, VP of Sanguine Legal Solutions, says this to firms directly. As he put it on Personal Injury Mastermind: “Sometimes they’re not ready for lead gen, and I’m very open about that. Hey, let’s build a foundation first before we start burning money on leads.”
That is why the ten checks come in two halves. The first five are about your firm. The last five are about the provider. Run them in that order, because a provider can’t fix a gap on your side of the table.
What should you check about your own firm first?
Check that your firm can define, answer, fund and measure the leads it is about to pay for. If any of those four is missing, the test result will reflect your gap rather than the source.
1. Is your case appetite written down?
Your case appetite is the set of case types, injury tiers and markets you want, and the ones you will turn away. Write it down before you speak to a provider. A useful test: would two people on your intake team accept or reject the same lead for the same reason? If not, the provider has no fixed target to hit, and you have no fixed basis for a credit request.
2. Is your intake team ready for outbound calls to cold leads?
A branded caller has already chosen your firm. A third-party lead hasn’t, so your team has to make the call, earn the conversation and sell the firm from the first sentence. Anthony’s warning to firms that do well with inbound calls: “handling an outbound call from a third party lead provider is a completely different sort of dynamic for your group, and one we should look at before spending cash.” The same gap explains why branded and third-party conversion rates aren’t comparable.
3. Can you call every lead within two to three minutes?
Speed to lead is the time between a lead arriving and your first call to that person. Anthony’s rule for web form leads: “you have to get a call out within two to three minutes, preferably sooner, but immediate. There needs to be three to four phone calls a day for the first 72 hours.” That standard applies at 9pm on a Friday too. An answering service that takes messages is not intake. The Speed-to-Lead Self-Check compares your current first-call time and attempts with this guidance.
4. Can your budget run long enough to read the results?
A lead source test needs enough spend and enough time to produce signed cases and show whether they stay signed. Plan for several months, not a few weeks. Anthony’s view is that a campaign given three months has room to improve. He is also candid about the alternative: “Lead gen is not for everybody and if that’s making you feel uncomfortable, then let’s hold off on lead gen.” Running several small tests at once spreads the budget too thin to read any of them, which is why testing lead sources one at a time matters.
5. Can you track every source to signed cases and 90-day retention?
Tag each lead with its source in your CRM, then follow it to a signed case and beyond. The numbers that matter are want rate, conversion rate, cost per signed case, case tier mix and the 90-day drop rate. When Anthony tests a provider, he looks at “your conversion rate, your cost of acquisition, your drop rate after 90 days.” The Cost per Signed Case Calculator shows what a source is really costing you once spend and signed cases are in one place.
What should you check about the provider?
Check where the leads come from, how they reach your firm and what the contract actually commits the provider to. A pitch tells you what a provider wants you to believe; these five checks test it.
6. Does the provider generate its own traffic or aggregate it?
A lead generator runs its own advertising and controls the lead from the first click. A lead aggregator buys traffic or leads from other marketers and resells them. Anthony puts this question to every provider: “how are you generating your leads? Are you an aggregator?” With providers that generate their own traffic, he says, “I tend to see a higher stick rate.” Ask again after you scale, because providers under pressure for volume often start buying traffic. Our guide on how to vet a personal injury lead provider covers the follow-up questions.
7. Which delivery model fits your intake team?
Web form leads leave the first call to you. Live transfer leads need someone ready to pick up every transfer during the agreed hours. Signed retainer leads arrive signed but not yet loyal. On that last point Anthony is blunt: “You treat that signed case just like a lead.” Choose the model your team can actually support, not the one with the best-looking price.
8. What does “exclusive” mean in the contract?
Exclusive can mean the lead goes to your firm alone, that you are the only firm in a market or that the lead is yours for a set period. Those are very different promises. Get the definition in the agreement, and compare it with what you were told on the sales call. Our breakdown of exclusive vs. shared leads explains the trade-offs.
9. What does the credit policy actually cover?
A lead credit policy sets which leads you can return for a credit or replacement, and how. Check whether it covers invalid contact details, duplicates and leads outside your agreed criteria, how long you have to dispute a lead and what evidence the provider requires. A provider confident in its leads will put this in writing before you sign.
10. Can the provider show its consent records?
A consent record shows the wording the person saw, the timestamp, the source and which companies the consent covers. Consent to hear from one company is not automatically consent to hear from your firm. Ask to see sample records before you sign, and see what to require from providers on consent and lead data. Calling and consent rules change, so have your own counsel confirm what applies to your firm.
How do the ten checks fit together?
Each check has a clear pass and a clear warning sign. Use this table as a one-page review before any lead source test.
| # | Check | A good answer looks like | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Case appetite | Case types, tiers and markets written down and shared with intake | “We take anything decent” |
| 2 | Outbound intake | Staff trained to call and sell the firm to someone who never contacted it | Intake built only for inbound calls |
| 3 | Speed to lead | First call within two to three minutes, at every hour you accept leads | Leads wait in an inbox or go to an answering service |
| 4 | Test budget | Spend and timeframe set together, long enough to see 90-day results | A short test that ends before cases mature |
| 5 | Tracking | Every lead tagged by source and followed to a signed case and beyond | Reporting that stops at lead counts |
| 6 | Traffic source | The provider explains exactly where its leads come from | Vague answers, or a mix that changes as you scale |
| 7 | Delivery model | A model your team can support every day | Choosing on price alone |
| 8 | Exclusivity | A written definition in the agreement | “Exclusive” only on the sales call |
| 9 | Credit policy | Clear criteria, a dispute window and a written process | Credits at the provider’s discretion |
| 10 | Consent records | Sample records showing wording, timestamp, source and scope | No records, or consent that doesn’t name your firm |
What should you do if your firm fails one of the firm-side checks?
Fix the gap before you fund a test. A source tested on top of a known gap produces a result you can’t trust, and you will have paid for it.
Start with the cheapest fixes. Writing down your case appetite and setting up source tracking cost time, not money. Speed to lead and after-hours coverage usually need staffing changes, so schedule them before launch rather than during the test. If the budget check is the one that fails, wait until you can fund a test properly. A rushed test that ends early tells you nothing about the source.
How does Sanguine Legal Solutions help before you spend on a lead source?
Sanguine Legal Solutions vets and tests lead sources for personal injury law firms. It does not sell leads. It starts with your firm, reviewing your case appetite, markets, volume goals and intake capacity before suggesting any provider.
The work follows four steps: Vet. Test. Deliver. Manage.
- Vet: Review the source, the business behind it, its lead model, case focus, geography, consent approach, delivery method and commercial terms.
- Test: Look at how a source performs with real firms before introducing it more broadly.
- Deliver: Bring tested sources to firms whose case types, markets and intake capacity fit them.
- Manage: Stay involved after launch, so the firm and provider operate as agreed and deal with problems early.
No leads pass through Sanguine, and your firm contracts directly with any provider it chooses. See how we vet and test lead sources.
Frequently asked questions
Who is responsible for compliance when a firm buys personal injury leads?
Your firm remains responsible for the advertising and professional conduct rules in each state where it advertises or accepts cases. The provider is responsible for its own advertising, consent and calling practices. Have your own counsel review the provider’s model and contract before you sign.
How much budget do you need to test a lead source?
Enough to produce signed cases and to see whether those cases are still active at 90 days. That usually means several months of steady spend, not a few weeks. A small, short test mostly measures noise, so set the budget and the timeframe together before you start.
Are exclusive leads always better than shared leads?
No. Exclusive leads remove competition from other buyers, but they still need fast intake, and the contract decides what “exclusive” covers. Shared leads can work for a firm whose intake team is consistently faster than the competition.
What is the most important question to ask a lead provider?
Ask how it generates its leads. A provider that runs its own advertising controls consent, screening and duplicates from the first click, while an aggregator resells traffic it didn’t create. Ask again after you scale, because the mix can change.
How fast should a personal injury firm call a new web form lead?
Within two to three minutes of the lead arriving, and sooner where possible. Then make three to four call attempts a day for the first 72 hours, and keep following up for longer if your team has the capacity.
Does Sanguine Legal Solutions sell personal injury leads?
No. Sanguine Legal Solutions vets and tests lead sources and introduces personal injury law firms to providers that fit them. No leads pass through Sanguine, and the firm contracts directly with any provider it chooses.
Check your firm before you fund a test
Talk to Sanguine about your intake, case appetite and the lead sources that fit your firm before you commit budget.
Book a CallThis article is general commercial information, not legal advice. Sanguine Legal Solutions is not a law firm. Each law firm and provider is responsible for its own legal, ethical, privacy and regulatory compliance, including advertising, consent and TCPA obligations. Provider vetting and testing reflect information available at the time and are not a certification. Sanguine does not guarantee provider performance, lead quality, retained cases or return on spend.




